dark mode light mode Search

How to Determine If You Need A Roof Repair Or Replacement

How to Determine If You Need A Roof Repair Or Replacement

The decision on whether to repair or replace your roof is not easy to make. For homeowners, neither of the two is an easy decision to make as there are many things to consider. Mostly, homeowners may consider seeking professional help like this roofing Midland TX company.

However, you do not need to always consult on what to do as consultation can also take time and be costly. This article will give you a breakdown of the things you need to consider when determining whether you need repair or replacement for your roof.

Here are a few things that you can look into when your DIY roofs get damaged.

The Age Of Your Roof

According to experts, this is one of the top factors to consider when deciding whether to do replacement or repair. Like any other item, your roof has a lifespan, and it will start losing its color and shape once it reaches its old age. Therefore, you need to consider how long it has stayed over your head.

A good example is an asphalt roof that you should expect to last for around 12 to 15 years. After these years, you should start expecting signs of old age and develop a replacement plan. However, metal and tile roofs last longer than this, and you can think about replacement once there is a small issue rather than replacement.

Whether you are considering a professional or DIY roofing project, you will start noting some wear and tear signs. An old roof will be prone to damage as the materials used in making it begin to deteriorate. You can check for things like cracks, splits, and gaps when deciding whether to repair or replace.

If there is a damage of any kind, consider the size of the affected area. If it’s widespread, you may have to consider a replacement, and a small damaged area should get repaired before it becomes too late. A leaky roof is also a sign that you need repairs or a replacement. Remember to check the extent of the damage.

Type Of Roof

It is essential to remember the type of roof installed in your home when deciding whether to repair or replace it. However, this should go hand in hand with the kind of damage in your home. These two combined will help you determine what solution will fit your home.

For instance, you do not need to quickly think of replacement if your vinyl roof gets damaged slightly. Vinyl roofs tend to last longer than most types of roofs, and thus there is no need to replace it quickly. You can repair the damaged area and use the roof for a long time without replacements.

However, vinyl roofs can get severely damaged by rain and snow. Therefore, you need to consider the occurrence that caused the damage; if it is a storm, there could be more damage than your eyes can see. Such instances wear down vinyl roofs and call for replacements as soon as possible.

Composite roofs, on the other hand, are more resistant to fire than vinyl roofs. If you have this type of roof, you may consider repairs over replacements if a fire is the cause of the damage. Therefore, the type of roof is a vital factor that you need to remember as a homeowner.

Examination Of Shingles 

One of the best ways to decide whether your roof needs repair or replacement is by examining the various parts. For example, you can check for broken, missing, or curling shingles. Although you may be able to see some of these things, you may require a professional at some point.

Professional roofers take time to assess the entire roof and determine what could be causing leakages or any other issues. They will advise you on your next course of action, depending on the state of your roof. For instance, if the shingles are in perfect condition, there is no need for a total overhaul.

However, depending on the roof type, some things like holes, rotting areas, and damaged areas could signal a collapsing roof. These require immediate action and, most likely, a replacement of the entire roof. It is necessary to act fast as it may collapse unexpectedly and cause more damage.

As mentioned earlier, expert roofers are the best for roof assessments. There are several underlying issues with roofs that you need to check carefully. However, it is a professional roofing expert who can do that, and therefore, you need to find a trusted one.

 How to Determine If You Need A Roof Repair Or Replacement

The Amount Of Leakage

One of the significant problems that you may experience with roofs is leakages. A leakage can have a severe impact on the remaining part of the roof, making repair difficult. Besides, it can cause stains on the ceiling and run-down walls making your house look untidy.

When deciding whether to repair or replace, you need to assess the amount of water flowing through your roof. If there is too much water that you can observe stains on walls and ceilings, then it is time to get rid of your current roof and find a replacement.

However, some leakages can be minor and may be unnoticeable for some time. The best thing to do with such is replacing the broken area before it causes extensive damage. Besides, you can find a professional to assess the rest of the roof to determine its state.

According to expert roofers, leaking roofs are relatively easy to repair. The difficult task is tracking down the leakage to find out the leaking point on your roof. A professional roofing expert can help you identify leakage points with ease and help repair them.

Your Budgetary And Long Term Needs

When it comes to budget, you need to consider how much you are ready to spend on the roof at this moment. Sometimes, you may be willing to pay a considerable sum and get a roof replacement to avoid repairs now and then. That means your budget could be on the higher side, especially if you had expected a replacement soon.

However, sometimes you may not have enough money to replace your roof. The damage may have been unpredictable, for instance, resulting from a natural disaster. The best thing to do is repair the roof with what you can afford and schedule a replacement later when there is enough money.

On the other hand, your long-term plans can also affect the decision to repair or replace your roof. For instance, there is no need to replace a roof when planning to construct a new house with a different roof in a month. Repairing it to last for the short period you need it is the best option.

If you intend to stay in the same house for a long time to come, you can decide to replace the roof. It will help reduce the costs of frequently repairing it if it has grown weak. Besides, you get to solve any underlying issues that could have caused problems in the future.


There are several options to consider when your roof gets damaged. As seen in this article, repair or replacement are some of the most common alternatives to consider. In some cases, you may consider partial re-roofing if one part of your roof gets severely damaged.

Before choosing the best course of action, you should check out all of the above factors. Ensure you do not spend a lot of money in replacing a roof that could otherwise get repaired.